Fear as Motivator – Retirement Investment Preparedness and Paralysis

The Employee Benefits Research Institutes’s 2009 Retirement Confidence Survey could be called the 2009 Retirement Crippling Fear Survey.  Those surveyed who voiced confidence in a comfortable retirement dropped to 13%, the lowest in 16 years of surveys.  72% of people plan to work after retirement, which is essentially not retiring.  32% think Social Security will save them.

We don’t need a survey to tell us that the stock market, along with the value of most Americans’ 401(k)s, has dropped like the New Year’s Eve ball in Times Square. We know this.  We also know that many employers are no longer matching 401(k) funds, further devaluing a 401(k) and demotivating the 401(k) holder.  We can safely assume that the federal government is not prepared to support us in retirement.  None of this is new information, but nothing seems to change.

Entrust New Direction, of course, has a horse in the retirement investment race.  We want more people to open self-directed IRAs for many reasons, obvious and not.  But if millions of Americans are not financially ready for retirement, all the rest of us will be adversely affected as well, whether by higher taxes or stress on the public safety net or some as-yet-unknown factor.   So it’s in your best interest and mine that as many Americans as possible are financially comfortable in retirement.

Now to motivate these millions of un-confident eventual retirees.  Is fear the best motivator?  This is, of course, a nebulous question.

If the fear is immediately apparent (a drooling bear moving rapidly toward you), it’s the best motivator.  But how many of us think about retirement savings while working full-time or overtime, raising a family, practicing hobbies, enjoying friends – basically, while living a full life?  If the fear of a destitute retirement doesn’t spur you every day/week/month to save and plan, then it’s not the best motivator.

Most people fear the unknown.  EBRI reports that 44% don’t know how much they’ll need for retirement.  Not very confident numbers.  The numbers indicate, however, that ignorance may not be bliss.  If we Americans don’t know how much to save and we don’t have confidence in the amount we’re saving, we must not fear the unknown, or we must not be adequately motivated by that fear.

We may be motivated by a different kind of fear.  From a different point of view, the unknown may be contributing to our collective dilemma.  Most people don’t know about self-directed retirement accounts, and many of those who do know about it think they won’t be able to successfully grow their retirement account on their own.  They may not know what to invest in, or how to do so.

We talked about the fear of retiring without sufficient funds.  This is a distant fear, certainly not viceral, not real to most of us.  What is real to most of us is the fear of losing our money.  What is real is watching the numbers fall every quarter, knowing that money you earned and saved is now gone, due to some individual or some company’s bad decisions or bad luck.

But, as we’ve heard over and over during this recession, people with 401(k)s don’t look at their statement.  They’re too scared to see more losses.  But if they’re not looking at their statements, they won’t close their 401(k) and start investing in a Roth, they won’t even shift to a safer less-volatile sanctioned and commissioned investment. They’re paralyzed.

Many financial “experts” talk about waiting out the storm.  They say that the stock market will come back within a decade or two.  Maybe so.  No one really knows.  Even if the stock market does come back, there is no guarantee we won’t go through a similar recession again.

If you’re reading this, you likely already hold a self-directed IRA or you are considering one.  Maybe you were able to shake off the retirement paralysis, look at your statement, and do something to change the status quo.  Good for you.

Now for your sake and mine, spread the word.  Tell your story, I’ll tell mine, and maybe together we can shake enough Americans out of their retirement investment paralysis so they can start controlling their own destiny. Maybe together we can inspire people to look at their 401(k) statements and stop the bleeding.

Nebula photo courtesy of koolkao.